Wed 11 Nov 2026 ·
Get the list
Breaking-ish

Six Years, Out in Three: A Sentencing Guide for People Who Were Promised Justice

A terror label, a stabbing, an arson attempt and a sentence you could serve between two Croke Park matches. The maths, explained.

A man has been convicted of attempted murder of a garda in Dublin city centre. The court heard he had attempted arson on a pub a few days earlier. The State had classed the case as terrorism. He has been sentenced to six years, and the usual arithmetic says he will be out in three. Here is how the system will explain that to you.

1A terrorism label that changes nothing

The State says the offence was terrorism. The sentence says it was a Tuesday. Officials will tell you the label is about "recognising the seriousness of the offence", a phrase that has the same effect on a sentence as a sticker on a parking ticket.

2The arson that was just a warm-up

Attempted arson on a pub, a stabbing of an officer, and a plan to attack someone over their politics. Under the sentencing guidelines these are filed as separate incidents, each shorter than the one before, so that by the time the judge adds them up the total looks like a bad week rather than a pattern.

3The six-year sentence, and the three-year release

Six years, less remission, less time on remand, less "good behaviour", and the public is told it is a "robust" sentence. Nobody has explained what the bit after the comma means, and nobody is going to ask the Minister on the radio.

AdvertisementYour brand here. Mid-scroll. Thumb hovering.This space is for sale. Advertise with B8ed →

4The guard who has to live with the outcome

The officer who was stabbed will be asked to attend a victim support meeting, read a statement on the review of the review, and wait for a letter explaining the timeline. The sentence has been given the same length of time that the court took to get the case listed.

5The promise of a review

The Department of Justice will announce a review of sentencing for terror-related offences. It will report after the next election, the question will have been forgotten by then, and the next person to be sentenced will be told that the review is "ongoing".

The Dublin Business Desk is committed to fair justice for victims and to asking why sentences are so short for serious violence. This is satire about sentencing policy. It makes no claim about any religion, community or the individual involved.

This is a Satirical News story. It is satire. It did not happen, and any resemblance to an actual person is a coincidence. More on that.

Your reaction